Anasayfa / Special File / AGAINST THE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME

Special File

  • 510

AGAINST THE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME

image

The artificial intelligence and automation will apparently leave millions of people unemployed. According to some, the solution is to provide a ‘universal basic income’ to these people so that they can afford their life. Facebook founder Zuckerberg says that everyone can thus have a cushion to try new ideas. Silicon Valley startup accelerator Y Combinator’ research arm has already launched a pliot programme in which up to 100 recipient households will get $12,000 to $18,000. The idea is to see whether the universal basic income will be successful in the long term.

Antonio Garcia Martinez, one of the former product managers of Facebook, who worked in Silicon Valley for many years, left desperately everything and escaped to an island. To explain the reason of his attitude, “I’ve seen what the world will look like in a few years and that was enough for me” he said.

According to Martinez, the artificial intelligence and robotic technologies developed in Silicon Valley will deteriorate the global economic balances in a much shorter time than anticipated and half of the global population will remain unemployed over the next 30 years. Furthermore, this outlook will not only cause unemployment but will open the way to the collapse of civilization as well.

Fortune Turkey September issue features the issue of ‘universal basic income’ proposed as a cushion against this threat seen as a potential leading to the collapse of the civilization. This system foresees to make a standard payment to people. And what’s more, it doesn’t attach this compensation to some conditions. Some may choose to spend this money on holiday, entertainment and some others may invest it to entrepreneurial skills. Sam Altman, the 31-yearold CEO of Silicon Valley startup accelerator Y Combinator, believes that if economic trends continue on their current trajectory, that hypothetical deposit in your account may prove a critical part of your future. Altman, the precocious investor whose firm helped launch stars like Airbnb, Zenefits and Dropbox, is using real-world experimentation to learn whether UBI can stand up to such critiques.

THEY DON’T NEED TO DO ANYTHING

Y Combinator’s research arm has launched a pilot program in which up to 100 recipient households will get $12,000 to $18,000 this year in exchange for nothing. They’re asked to submit to occasional surveys but there’s no penalty for failing to do so. The idea is to give people money without preconditions and observe what they choose to do. If the pilot is successful, Y Combinator will launch a much larger study , likely a five-year experiment involving thousands of households in multiple states. Within a few years, Altman hopes his team will have something that has far proved elusive: Proof of whether UBI can have a longterm positive impact.

“It’s not for me to tell policymakers what to do and I don’t know what the best policy is” Altman says. But in a time of unprecedented disruption, it’s time to find out; after all, he adds, “people can smell automation on the horizon.”

83 % OF JOBS BELOW $20 AN HOUR WOULD DISAPPEAR

A University of Oxford study from 2013 estimated that 47% of US jobs may be at risk within the next two decades because of advances in artificial intelligence and automation. Last year, the White House Council of Economic Advisers estimated that workers making below $20 an hour would have 83% chance of losing their jobs to robots in that span. Those odds dropped as workers’ education and income levels grew. But as software gets smarter that too is subject to change: Companies will eliminate even jobs that were long considered immune from technological displacement.

That’s where Altman’s $1,500 comes in. One potential means of blunting the impact of automation involves providing each personworking or not-with a minimum payment, for life, regardless of income or other mitigating factors. Universal basic income (UBI) would insulate displaced workers from poverty and quell the potential for unrest during a profound and painful economic transition.

Theoretically, it might spur innovation and encourage people to take entrepreneurial risks. It would almost certainly alter the definition of “work” by attaching compensation to whatever people choose to do with their time, including absolutely nothing.

Floated by economists and political theorists for decades, the notion of basic income is enjoying new prominence today. That’s particularly true in Silicon Valley where several of the entrepreneurs developing the very technologies that fuel fears of dystopian future, have endorsed UBI as a potential fix. Governments in developed and emerging nations alike have warmed to the concept, launching a bushel of pilot projects. And the inherently “lefty” idea has drawn growing support from libertarians and conservatives, particularly those who view traditional welfare mechanisms as bloated, wasteful and inefficient.

Of course, the widening support by no means makes UBI politically palatable. Critics have a buffet of objections to choose from- it undermines productivity, it rewards laziness. There’s no doubt that it would be unprecedentedly, astronomically expensive.

This concept also violates a core tenet of capitalism, by assuming that this technological revolution, unlike others before it, won’t create better jobs tomorrow to replace the ones it erases today.

A CATALYST FOR ENTREPRENEURSHIP

In May, speaking to Harvard’s graduating class, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg made a case for UBI as a means to mitigate automation’s downsides and as a catalyst for entrepreneurship. “We should have a society that measures progress not just by economic metrics like GDP but by how many of us have a role we find meaningful” Zuckerberg said. “We should explore ideas like universal basic income, to make sure that everyone has a cushion to try new ideas.”

That idea is gaining currency among tech leaders. In November, Tesla and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk told CNBC “there’s pretty good chance we end up with a universal basic income due to automation.” And in February, eBay founder Pierre Omidyar donated nearly half a million dollars through his philanthropic organization to support a basic income experiment in Kenya. The tech elite’s burgeoning concern could be described as part moral obligation, part enlightened self interest. Many of them share the view that technologies that have generated huge amounts of concentrated wealth will soon be responsible for devastating labor market upheavals. The fact that a middle class gutted by unemployment doesn’t bode well for gadget sales likely isn’t lost on them either.

If the core problem in a robotics-led world is the average worker’s lack of income, the thinking goes, then UBI could-theoretically-mitigate it by providing a financial floor below which people cannot fall. It’s the rare kind of societal problem for which the solution may be to simply throw money at it

Of course, how much to throw, and to whom is a point of enormous contention. In the US, a number oft-cited by critics is $ 3.2 trillion – the cost of giving $10,000 a year to each and every citizen. That’s about %19 of GDP.

Advocates of UBI counter that much of that money could be recovered by rolling up existing social programs like welfare and Social Security. Even so, new costs could be measured in trillions for any program that could earn the label “universal”.

Altman believes that robots are likely to solve the cost problem, even as they eliminate jobs, by creating unprecedented productivity and wealth-perhaps even doubling GDP.”If we need it, we’ll be able to afford it,” he says of UBI.

But cost isn’t where he’s focusing now: The Y Combinator team is far more concerned with collecting conclusive data about whether UBI can create the stability to allow people to find meaning in new kind of works-the kind of data that could persuade policymakers to make a trillion-dollar bet.

EXPERIMENTS ARE IN THE WORKS IN SEVERAL COUNTRIES

However, they are not the only ones looking. Experiments are in the works in at least a dozen countries including Spain, the Netherlands, Kenya, Uganda and India. The city of Glasgow in Scotland has undertaken a feasibility study for the first UBI pilot in the UK. In January, the Finnish social services agency Kela launched a program that selected 2,000 citizens who were already receiving unemployment benefits and offered them an extra 560 euros monthly. This summer the Canadian province of Ontario will begin a basic income trial involving up to 4,000 families. And Switzerland last year voted on the idea of a national basic income in a referendum but it lost.

A similar pilot-the one funded in large part by Omidyar of eBay-began in October in Kenya. It will give 6,000 people in across 40 villages 2,280 shillings per month-about $22-for a full 12 years (another 11,500 people across an additional 80 villages will participate in a short trial). The Kenya effort aims to be the largest, most extensive basic income trial to date. . While it’s too new to have produced conclusions, there’s already evidence that recipients have used the cash to buy motorbikes, livestock, fishing nets and other vehicles of economic empowerment.

Y Combinator team too is exploring what $1,500 a month can buy in Oakland. For most, is doesn’t buy a free ride. The rising cost of living in the Bay Area has spilled over into what was until recently one of its rare affordable enclaves: Median rents in Oakland have crept toward $3,000, ranking it among the nation’s most expensive markets. But the money can still help residents cope with stagnant wage growth. And for Altman and his allies, it buys data-driven insight into human behavior. Will Oaklanders be more likely to become couch potatoes or self-taught coders? To retrain or tune out? The answers might help buy legitimacy for UBI –serious consideration of an idea long dismissed as practically unfeasible, politically untenable, or both.

Autonomous vehicles on the streets, automated traders on the floor and factories where people are a distant memory. The benefits could be enormous but this futurewith artificial intelligence performing the business functions once reserved to us-is where basic income might make sense. “A lot of people, politicians especially, will lie and say they are going to stop jobs from going away” Altman says. “That’s not going to happen. Technology is going to come. Jobs are going to change. I want to figure out how to make this new world work for everybody.”